These are the top 20 resources, and retail listings I found about beanie babies for sale on craigslist. I've created this page to highlight the most recently updated (and useful!) resources for "beanie babies for sale on craigslist". This guide was updated: 2024-09-19.
The average price for "beanie babies for sale on craigslist" is $4,513 for new, sold eBay auctions. Used beanie babies for sale on craigslist sold eBay prices are $41. New sold listings averaged $4472 higher vs used sold listings for a difference of 10,907.32%. New current listings averaged $294 higher vs used current listings for a difference of 9.11%. There are 138 new listings for beanie babies for sale on craigslist on sale right now. There are 162 used or pre-owned auctions for sale on eBay currently.
As an eBay Partner, I may be compensated if you make a purchase. CheckAFlip is powered by readers like you. Learn more
$3,520average price
The average current price for new "beanie babies for sale on craigslist" is $3,520 from the last 138 listings.
$499.99 New+$70.00 shipping ENTIRE RARE BEANIE BABY COLLECTION - Free shipping, MINT condition! |
$200.00 New+$7.32 shipping Ty Beanie Babies Bears Collection |
$750.00 New+$150.00 shipping beanie babies collection |
$800.00 New+$7.58 shipping New ListingBeanie Babies & More |
$8.00 New+$4.43 shipping TY beanie babies Beautiful!! Price Each! |
$4,513average price
The average sold price for new "beanie babies for sale on craigslist" is $4,513 from the last 240 listings.
$25.00 New+$93.87 shipping Lot of 26 TY Beanie Babies Stuffed Plush Animals |
$282.77 New+$30.45 shipping Teddy Teal 2nd/1st Gen Old Face OF Ty Beanie Baby MWMT-MQ Authenticated TBB |
$17.25 New+$19.02 shipping Ty Beanie Babies 1999 Cheeks Baboon With Tag Protector |
$50.00 New+$116.55 shipping ty beanie babies lot Of 33 |
$1,000,000.00 New+$28.92 shipping EXTREMELY RARE!! Ty Beanie Baby, Princess Diana Mint. **Errors Read Description. |
$3,226average price
The average current price for used beanie babies for sale on craigslist is $3,226 from the last 162 listings.
$250.00 Used+$42.31 shipping Seventeen various beanie babies with tags valuable ones No issues all good to go |
$1,000.00 Used+$46.49 shipping collectibles beanie babies |
$200.00 Used+$26.26 shipping ty beanie babies RARE COLLECTION W/TAGS 1990s Edition Make An Offer |
$59.99 Used+$31.94 shipping 22 Ty Beanie Babies Some Are Very RARE 150$ OBO Message For Any Questions |
$45.00 Used+$35.83 shipping Collection Of Ty Beanie babies |
$41average price
The average sold price for used beanie babies for sale on craigslist is $41 from the last 240 listings.
$1.00 UsedFree shipping BEANIE BABIES FOR SALE!! INDIVIDUALS OR GROUPINGS YOUR CHOICE. GREAT CONDITION! |
$20.50 UsedFree shipping 7- TY Beanie Babies Mixed Lot Various LOT O |
$41.00 Used+$8.60 shipping LOOK TY BEANIE BABIES BLUE ELEPHANT USED ESTATE SALE WITH TAG |
$34.96 Used+$5.07 shipping Ty Beanie Baby - Retired - “Happy” The Hippo 1993 Original Black Ink Tag |
$4.25 Used+$11.85 shipping ty beanie babies lot |